Thursday, 12 December 2024

The universe of numeric domain names

Introduction

As has been remarked in a number of previous overviews, the availability of short, memorable, unregistered domain names across popular domain-name extensions (top-level domains, or TLDs) has increasingly been running low over recent years. This issue presents potential difficulties for entities looking to launch new brand names, and is likely to drive a push towards other approaches, such as the use of novel or invented brand names and/or alternative TLDs (including 'dot-brands')[1,2]. One additional possible alternative is the use of numeric domain names (i.e. those consisting only of the characters 0 to 9), which are already popular in certain markets such as China, where their use can circumvent language barriers and particular numbers may have specific cultural significance.

In this article, I consider the universe of numeric domain names which are already registered, using the ever-popular .com TLD as a case study, giving insights into registration and usage patterns.

Overview

As of 21-Nov-2024, domain name zone file analysis shows that there are 1,008,834 unique registered .com domains with second-level domain (SLD) names (i.e. the part to the left of the dot) consisting of numeric digits only[3]. These range in length from 1 character (one instance in the zone file, 1.com, a domain reserved by IANA) to 63 characters (32 instances) (Figure 1).

Figure 1: Numbers of registered numeric .com domain names, by SLD length (logarithmic scale)

Next, it is informative to exclude any domains beginning with a leading '0' (i.e. concentrating only on those where the SLD is a 'natural' or 'counting' number - of which there are 928,086 such examples). Considering all numeric domains from 10.com upwards (i.e. those with a length of two or more characters), we find that (for example) all numbers under 1,000 except 215.com, 968.com and 992.com appear in the .com zone file as the SLDs of registered domains - and even these have active whois records and appear unavailable for registration.

Furthermore, in total, there are only 93 numeric domains with SLDs under 10,000 which are absent from the zone file but, similarly, all of these also have active whois entries. Accordingly, there are no numeric domains of four characters (i.e. digits) in length or shorter which are available for registration.

In fact, there appear to be only ten numeric .com domains with SLDs under 100,000 which appear not to have valid whois records and may therefore be unregistered. However, even these appear to be unavailable for standard purchase - seven of them are listed as 'taken' and three of them (36923.com, 65879.com, 81632.com) are deemed 'premium' (according to GoDaddy), with purchase prices in excess of £1,000.

Usage trends and patterns

As an indication of the typical nature of usage of numeric domains, it is instructive firstly to consider the set of 988 domains in the .com zone file with SLDs which are numeric strings below 1,000. Of these, 331 (34%) generate some sort of live website response (i.e. an HTTP status code of 200). It is noteworthy that, of the 224 homepages configured with a webpage title, 99 (44%) are in far-eastern Scripts (mostly Chinese), highlighting the popularity of numeric domains in this region. Also of particular interest is the number of examples where the numeric domain name itself is very closely associated with the brand identity, with notable examples including '76 Gas Stations' (76.com), 'TheNumber118118' (118.com), '311' (music artist; 311.com), '555 International' (555.com), 'Six Eight Six' (apparel; 686.com), and a significant number of casino websites, including '444.com' (444.com), '777 casino' (777.com) and '888' (888.com). Other domains in the dataset also use names of particular relevance, such as 107.com, which re-directs to a prime-number calculator. The dataset also includes examples of what could be considered brand infringements, such as 168.com, which resolves to an e-commerce website (Figure 2), perhaps trading off the popularity of the well-known Chinese marketplace 1688.com. Many of the other domains analysed resolve to pages offering the domain name for sale.

Figure 2: The e-commerce website at 168.com

Several of the longer domain names in the wider dataset appear to have been registered purely for their collectability or tradability (cf. trends seen in blockchain domain names[4] and Web2 domain 'clubs'[5]). Many examples feature repetitions of the same character or group of characters, whilst others feature alternative significance, such as lists of counting numbers, the Fibonacci sequence, or the digits of mathematical constants such as pi (π) or e.

Additionally, there are 818 domains with SLDs consisting only of the digits 0 and 1, and which may be intended to be significance in the context of binary notation. This is particularly noticeable given the peaks in numbers of domains with SLD lengths of multiples of eight characters (Figure 3), given that blocks of eight binary digits (one byte) are a standard way of encoding regular ASCII characters[6].

Figure 3: Numbers of registered numeric .com domain names with SLDs consisting only of the digits 0 and 1, by SLD length (logarithmic scale)

Indeed, if we consider examples where the length is 32, 40, 48 or 56 characters, we find that the SLD names are, in many cases, in fact binary representations of other terms, including brand names (see Appendix A). The exact purpose of these domains - beyond collectability and attempts at monetisation through their sale - is not clear, though some do feature content relevant to the brand referenced in their name, or other material where the binary encoding appears to be a way of 'hiding' the name of the site (Figure 4).

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

Figure 4: Examples of live website content on 'binary' numeric domain names - SLDs are:

  • (a) 010001110110111101101111011001110110110001100101 ('Google')[7] and 011001110110111101101111011001110110110001100101 ('google')
  • (b) 01111001011011110111010101110100011101010110001001100101 ('youtube')
  • (c) 01101000011000010110001101101011 ('hack')
  • (d) 0100000101010111010100110110001101100010 ('AWScb' - apparently in reference to 'AWS Community Builders')

Amongst the remainder of the domains, there is doubtless a range of other use-cases. For example, there are 1,162 domains in the dataset with SLDs 11 characters in length and beginning with a '0' - i.e. potentially consistent with the format of a telephone number in various countries (Figure 5).

Figure 5: Examples of 'telephone number' domain names: (top to bottom) 07077777777.com; 07178888888.com; 07712361119.com; 07759158517.com[8]

Discussion

The universe of numeric domain names sits alongside the more familiar text-based options, and provides an interesting alternative in terms of branding options and use-cases, particularly in view of the continuing lack of availability of brandable names. Currently, over one million numeric domain names have been registered just on the .com extension.

Numerics are particularly popular in the Chinese-speaking world, where particular numbers can have special cultural significance (e.g. the association of '8' with wealth and fortune, due to the similarity in pronunciation to the character of the same meaning), or where other similarities in pronunciation can convey implied meanings. For example, three highly-priced domain sales in 2021 (2698.com, 8499.com, 9599.com) were for domains ending with '98' or '99', similar to the Chinese terms for 'being rich for a long time' and 'for a long long time'[9]. Moreover, in view of the universal understanding and appeal of numbers, two of the ten most popular Chinese websites are 163.com and 360.cn.

More generally, numeric domain names can be extremely versatile and can convey specific brand messaging, with some very expensive sales reported - these include 360.com ($17M), 123.com ($3.2M), 114.com ($2.1M), 520.com ($1.6M) and 999.com ($1.2M)[10].

Numerics may also be amenable to familiar types of brand abuse, such as the use of popular, common or other strings which may be similar to (numeric) brand terms to drive traffic to third-party, potentially infringing content.

Moreover, there have been instances of UDRP disputes involving numeric domains, such as the 2016 case brought by Cube Limited, the owner of a number of gambling-related marks named '188', against the registrant of a group of eight six-digit numeric .com domains all beginning with 188 (and displaying advertisements relating to betting) and resulting in the transfer of the domains[11]. A year earlier, the owner of 11315.com - trading as '11315 Credit Services' - had won the transfer of 11315.so[12]. The list of UDRP cases from 2024[13] includes a dispute regarding the domain name 100101.art[14,15]. The domain formerly resolved to an NFT marketplace and now displays a parking page following successful transfer to the complainant, the owner of the EU word mark '10101'.

Other attractive characteristics of numeric domains are also apparent from the dataset. It is clear, for example, that collectable and tradable domain names are of appeal to some users, as is the use of binary encoding to 'hide' brand names or other terms within the domain name for sites which - in some cases - may also be of concern or infringing for other reasons.

Appendix A: List of binary numeric .com domain names

Domain name
                                                                                                 
SLD length
(characters)
                       
Decoding of
SLD name
                       
  00110001001100110011001100110111.com 32   1337
  01000011010010000100000101010100.com 32   CHAT
  01000100011001010100011001101001.com 32   DeFi
  01001100011011110111011001100101.com 32   Love
  01001101010001010101010001000001.com 32   META
  01001101011000010111001001110011.com 32   Mars
  01001101011001010111010001100001.com 32   Meta
  01100010011010010110111001100111.com 32   bing
  01100010011011000110111101100111.com 32   blog
  01100011011010000110000101110100.com 32   chat
  01100011011011110110010001100101.com 32   code
  01100011011011110110110001100101.com 32   cole
  01100011011011110111001001110000.com 32   corp
  01100100011000010111010001100001.com 32   data
  01101000011000010110001101101011.com 32   hack
  01101101011011110110111101101110.com 32   moon
  01110000011010000110100101101100.com 32   phil
  01110000011100110111001001100111.com 32   psrg
  01110010011000010110110001100110.com 32   ralf
  01110010011011110110111101110100.com 32   root
  01110011011010000110111101110000.com 32   shop
  01110100011000010111100101100001.com 32   taya
  01110101011001100110111100001010.com 32   ufo
  01111000011011110111001001011111.com 32   xor_
  0011010000110010001100000000110100001010.com 40   420
  0100000101010011010000110100100101001001.com 40   ASCII
  0100000101010111010100110110001101100010.com 40   AWScb
  0100000101110000011100000110110001100101.com 40   Apple
  0110111001101111011011000111010001100101.com 40   nolte
  0111010001100101011100110110110001100001.com 40   tesla
  010000010110110001101001011000110110100101100001.com 48   Alicia
  010000010110110101100001011110100110111101101110.com 48   Amazon
  010001110100111101001111010001110100110001000101.com 48   GOOGLE
  010001110110111101101111011001110110110001100101.com 48   Google
  010010100100000101010010010101100100100101010011.com 48   JARVIS
  010100110110100101110010011010010111010101110011.com 48   Sirius
  011000100110100101101110011000010111001001111001.com 48   binary
  011000110110111101101110011011000110000101101110.com 48   conlan
  011001110110111101101111011001110110110001100101.com 48   google
  011100000110000101111001011100000110000101101100.com 48   paypal
  011100110110010101110010011001110110100101101111.com 48   sergio
  011101000110100001110010011001010110010100100000.com 48   three
  011101110110010101100010001101000110000101101001.com 48   web4ai
  01000001011100100110110101100001011011100110010001101111.com 56   Armando
  01011010010001010101001001001111010011110100111001000101.com 56   ZEROONE
  01100010011001010110001101101000011101000110110001100101.com 56   bechtle
  01100010011010010111010001100011011011110110100101101110.com 56   bitcoin
  01100010011010010111010001100110011011000110100101110000.com 56   bitflip
  01100010011010010111010001100110011011000110100101110001.com 56   bitfliq
  01100011011010000110000101110100010001110101000001010100.com 56   chatGPT
  01111001011011110111010101110100011101010110001001100101.com 56   youtube

References

[1] 'Patterns in Brand Monitoring' (D.N. Barnett, Business Expert Press, 2025), Chapter 9: 'Domain landscape analysis'

[2] https://circleid.com/posts/a-review-of-the-2024-threat-landscape-and-implications-for-domain-security

[3] Note that this overview is based on the list of domains present in the .com zone file as of the date of analysis. However, the absence of a domain from the zone file does not necessarily mean that the name is unregistered and available, as other factors (such as the domain having being put 'on hold', or having no associated nameservers) may result in the domain being absent from the file. For example, the majority of one-letter names have been explicitly reserved by IANA (the Internet Assigned Numbers Authority) since the early 1990s.

[4] 'Patterns in Brand Monitoring' (D.N. Barnett, Business Expert Press, 2025), Chapter 13: 'Analysing trends in Web3'

[5] https://vision.io/ (formerly https://ens.vision/market)

[6] https://www.rapidtables.com/convert/number/binary-to-ascii.html

[7] Note that a .eth blockchain domain with the same SLD is offered for sale at https://vision.io/name/ens/010001110100111101001111010001110100110001000101.eth

[8] Screenshot courtesy of Wayback Machine (https://web.archive.org/web/20240913005719/http://07759158517.com/); telephone code consistent with that given at https://pitchbook.com/profiles/person/233703-37P

[9] https://domainnamewire.com/2021/09/16/three-recent-numeric-domain-sales-and-possible-chinese-meanings/

[10] https://www-bak.gname.com/news/20231101123113.html

[11] https://domaingang.com/domain-law/udrp-for-188-domains-puts-owners-of-short-numerics-in-danger/

[12] https://www.thedomains.com/2015/11/10/five-number-domain-lost-in-udrp/

[13] https://www.wipo.int/amc/en/domains/casesx/all.html

[14] D2024-1039, onezeroonezeroone d.o.o. vs. Gleb Martynov

[15] https://www.wipo.int/amc/en/domains/decisions/pdf/2024/d2024-1039.pdf

This article was first published on 12 December 2024 at:

https://www.iamstobbs.com/opinion/the-universe-of-numeric-domain-names

No comments:

Post a Comment

Unregistered Gems Part 6: Phonemizing strings to find brandable domains

Introduction The UnregisteredGems.com series of articles explores a range of techniques to filter and search through the universe of unregis...